Blu-Ray vs HD-DVD?

You are currently browsing comments. If you would like to return to the full story, you can read the full entry here: “Blu-Ray vs HD-DVD?”.

Filed under Blu-ray | . Taged: , ,

One Response to “Blu-Ray vs HD-DVD?”

  1. agb90spruce says:

    Better how?

    Video and audio quality are essentially identical. Both store and will output 1080p/24fps video (or lower resolution). Both use the same advanced audio formats.

    See the first link for a comparison. Each has areas where it is at least theoretically "better", (e.g. bitrates, storage capacity, mandatory features), but none make a practical difference.

    Arguably HD DVD is a more mature and stable hardware platform (Blu-ray has only just adopted the 2nd stage of a 3 stage specification). And lower end HD DVD players (1080i output rather than 1080p … but you can’t tell the difference on most HDTVs) are less expensive than Blu-ray.

    But it’s pretty much a wash.

    I suspect, depending on what each of you mean by "better" you are both right.

    See the second link for a NY times article that pretty much sums it up …. both HD DVD and Blu-ray are most likely fated to remain niche formats endorsed by those able to benefit and willing to pay the premium prices associated.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.